PRE-ORDER BETWEEN A ROCK AND A HOT PLACE

I READ A BOOK

In preparation for Taylor’s impending departure I read a book called “LETTING GO  – A Parents Guide to Understanding the College Years.”

It’s the WHAT TO EXPECT WHEN YOU’RE EXPECTING for the freshman parent and is clearly very popular as it’s  the fifth edition. So my guess is most people didn’t throw it across the room the way I did when it challenged their perceptions of life.

It covers many topics.  It has a chapter on picking your classes and things I don’t really care about. I never cared about what classes she took in high school and I don’t really care about her classes in college. She will pick what makes her happy and if she doesn’t like them she will figure out how to muddle through or transfer out.

Though I’m sure I can come off as an in your face mom. I ‘m a very out of your face mom when it comes to certain things that many moms are all over their kids about.

What she studies and how she studies it is really her business and I’ve never helped with homework. I barely did my own; the idea of actually doing someone else’s is appalling to me.

But the biggest thrust of this book is how to back off and get hell out of their lives and fast.  According to this book, you should throw your kid in the deep end whether they can swim or not and drive away immediately and not matter what do not call them. They may call you but chances are they won’t, but don’t you dare touch that dial. It’s like THE RULES for parents. If you ever want to take your child to dinner again do not call them and ask how they are, if they are alive or if they need anything. Just go back to your life as if you never had them. Really???? I  honestly don’t know how you pull that one off.

There is a section on how not to respond when your child is troubled, lonely or homesick, and they reach out to you.  LETTING GO says let them figure it out., get help from the school  Do not lend a hand or advice. One could compare it to Ferber, remember the guy who said let your kid cry all night until he throws up on himself – don’t dare go in the room they will eventually sleep through the night.  Now they’ve proven that there were a few holes in Ferber’s theory. Ferber admitted to them himself. I knew that – I let my kids sleep either in or next to my bed until they were at least six months old.

But back to LETTING GO these two yentas from Washington basically take the position you are a pain in the ass to your kid – you’ve had them long enough, now it’s time to let them go forever. After sophomore year chances are they won’t even come home for Christmas and if they do they will be miserable and want to get back “home”  -  their dorm as quickly as possible since you and your house which used to be their house now leaves them uncomfortable, nervous and feeling unwanted. They actually said things like that.

You can only imagine how well this sat with me.

And then, then, this is good; they say you will never heave a “regular relationship” with your child again. HELLO –things aren’t tough enough this summer I have to hear that. And pardon me what the F does that even mean? What pray-tell is a ”normal relationship?” Look I’m no dummy, I know the quotidian details of life will change – it will not be “chicken again???”  “Has anyone seen my cell phone charger?”  “I have dinner at Lizzie’s for advisee I won’t be home til nine.”  “Let’s have a coffee on Saturday and talk about it.”

It will be “quick your train is about to leave, I’ll send your sweater when I find it.”  “ No, I don’t mind if you spend your one paltry week of spring break with your friends in Florida instead of the lovely week in London we have planned for the FAMILY.”  “ “Summer abroad – wow – I wish I had done that.”   “Your boyfriend’s family for Christmas, I thought he was Jewish?”

I know that changes they are a coming….. I don’t know what they will feel like; my guess is not great cause when I do the dry runs I break down in tears. But I will adjust and I do know there is a natural progression in life.  And will be things to look forward to – I just don’t know what they are yet.

I know Taylor will grow up and have a life very separate from me and that is normal but I also hope and pray she will always have a strong relationship with her family. Home will not make her anxious but it will be a safe house when she needs it.

But you will never have a normal relationship with your child again??????????

Life is a fluid thing and you don’t have to be Buddha to figure it out. Yet what is normal at eighteen is very different than what is normal at twenty-eight than was what was normal at eight days. I think their ridiculous statement just throws a whole lot of gasoline on an already sparky fire.

When you read LETTING GO it sounds like most kids are miserable to come home, anxious around their parents and annoyed to ever hear from them.

I don’t think it has to be this way. Sure they are happy to be on their own, sure they are happy to find a world and define themselves on their own terms, but most kids I know have not been abused and many find comfort and solace at home and continue to until their parents die.

But the authors seem to find people to that back up their theory that a kid can’t be a person if a parent is within a two hundred mile radius. It’s also one of those give all the power to the kids books. You pay the bills sit in the background and only speak when spoken to. When did this happen that parents were only supposed to speak when spoken to?

One girl they interview says this.

“I think it’s important that I do all the calling, because then I don’t resent them. If they call, and I’m grumpy, the whole conversation goes downhill from there.”

Who is this nitwit?  I hope her parents hang up the phone next time deems to calls. In fact I think they should stop paying for her cell phone. We will see how fast she calls then.

I don’t plan on calling ten times a day or every day. Well, you know what I don’t know what I will do as I am not there yet. We are not there yet and what is normal for some kids is abhorrent to others. I know a girl at Brown that talks to her mother several times a day, she is not wimpy mama’s girl either she is on her way in a difficult career and has an identity totally separate from her powerful parents, but she still finds comfort and happiness in their presence and is happy to stay connected. I know kids who disappear and don’t look back. I know of kids who call every day during periods and then little during others. But normal is as normal does and it changes from family to family and day to day. And I don’t want to be told I will never have a normal relationship with my child again by anyone.

I also know that to make it work as a parent you do have to shut up about certain things.  Something that is not easy for me, but I am learning to do. How many of you have heard  DO NOT TELL ME WHAT TO DO lately?  And one will have to respect their choices even if they are not the choices you might make.  And most importantly all kids, even grown kids, kids in their fifties and sixties, cause lets face it every one is somebody’s kid wants to be acknowledged and seen for who they are – not who they are perceived to be or groomed to be, but who they really are and loved as that person in their entirety. If a parent any of us can pull that off, then I think the connection will stay strong.

Letting go is important though I’m not entirely sure what it really means. The one thing I know I am letting go of is this book. I’m having a yard sale next week and it’s in the twenty-five cent pile.

Be Sociable, Share!

Posted in Freshman Mom

  • jane

    Having been where are are, I can only say that you are right
    on target, and LETTING GO is totally off the mark.

  • http://Blitzerfamily@yahoo.com Lynnda Blitzer

    I have heard about this book and many people have recommended it. I haven’t read it but if that is all the advice they have to offer…well I will save my 17.00.

    I agree that enabling your child to be thoughtless and self centered is not a good idea.

    Matthew left this morning for a short trip to June Lake with a couple of friends for a few days. We were having dinner with friends last night and I asked him to stop by and say goodbye to us before he left to spend the night at the house of the family with whom he would be leaving this morning.

    Needless to say….the dinner visit never happened. 10:30 pm and no Matthew…after a bitter phone call, lots of lecturing on my side and I am sorry…he is off on his trip. I received a text from him saying that he was sorry and this is how i responded:

    Matthew I know that it is easy to fall into a pattern of selfish behavior but believe me no one likes the feeling of being taken for granted or having been taken advantage of. You have been the focus of all my attention and energy for 18 years and I am facing the difficult challenge of letting you go. Please don’t make me turn my sadness into anger. It will not serve either of us well. I love you very much and want the best for you. I want you to have all of your dreams come true. I want you to be a strong and respected adult and to be trusted by everyone that is close to you both professionally and personally. This is how one makes a success of their life, by being aware and responsible and caring and courteous. Out in the real world you don’t get second chances. If you disappoint someone in business by not living up to your word or by treating someone carelessly, you very often will find that door closed to you the next time you come knocking. Pay attention now so that you won’t be sorry later. Be careful at the lake and drive safely. Make good choices and call home. I love you, Mom.

    Then I got into the bathtub and cried for an hour.

    It is good to know that others are going through this separation as dumbfounded by it as I am.

    Well, tomorrow is another day!

    Lynnda

  • tracey

    thank you lynnda for so bravely sharing that story. i relate too well. i think almost word for word i have said the same thing, followed by the identical action. what would we do without the bath tub??!!
    a friend of taylor’s today who is reading the posts said, “they are ok – but college is about the kids not the parents”
    i told her to tell the person to raise a few kids and call me in twenty-five years.
    again, thank you – your comments are well written, heart felt and oh so honest.
    love, t

  • Joscelyn

    I very rarely read books about how to raise a child. What happened to a mother’s instinct?
    Maybe sometimes we can be wrong ,but so are the books. Or maybe I should say the authors.
    Even though Piaget described different stages for children and they are constant and real, we have to take into account that each human being is different and within each stages in their lifes there will be different behavior and different feelings. Yes, we are angry and we are sad ( that’s “the general” ) what is particular to each of us is the the why, the when , the reason for it , and the degree of those feelings.Books cannot help us there, they would have to decode the “mothers genome”
    I agree with you, I rarely knew what courses she was taking,and I never understood why I was expected to go again for 12 years of school and homework. I had already done that, nobody should be expected to go for 24 or 36 or….(depending on how many kids you have).
    Of course , like everybody else I am going through a very painful separation, but I think it’s not us, it’s the system that makes us go through this. Has any one thought that in smaller countries kids go to university, usually in the same city,and that they go home in the evening? No dorms, no meal plans,no college, no nonsense.After high school you go directly to your career. You are focused from the begining.No 4 years of drowning in beer and trying to decide what to do with your life. You finish high school and you go into life. Do they make mistakes? Sure.Do they have to change careers because of the mistakes? Of course, but so do the kids here, they change mayors, they transfer etc..
    The real difference is that they separate in a gentler way, not by saying good bye to their parents, siblings,and home life, but by saying goodbye to their childhood,they are on their way to adulthood, not to college.

  • http://Blitzerfamily@yahoo.com Lynnda Blitzer

    Very good point about location. It is true that in the past most graduates went to college in the same city and at the very least, the same state where their families lived. Now with competition as intense as it is graduates have to toss their college net nationwide. The anxiety about college starts at the end of the sophomore year. Everyone starts to talk about how this upcoming junior year will be the most important year and that there is no room for error or stumble. Parents start to call college counselors and book 300.00 per hour appointments for their students with the idea that this will somehow give them a head start or leg up in the college application process. Dinner conversation revolves around SAT scores and college essays. Then their is always the terrible story about the kid that had straight A’s and an almost perfect SAT and wasn’t accepted to any of the colleges to which he/she applied. Everyone purses their lips and raises their eyebrows when they hear that so and so’s child wound up at city college. Like this is a fate worse than death!

    No wonder our kids start to freak out! The minute their junior year starts we are on them like stink on s*#t. We jump on airplanes and travel all over the country to “visit” colleges. Spend tons of money on hotels and meals and airfare to take a 30 minute look see and 3 months later can’t remember the details of any of the meetings and our notes are so hastily taken that they offer no help when referenced.

    After the tours the application process begins. Dining room tables are filled with information and calendars and color coded files screaming out due dates and essay topics. In the meantime our children are studying for the SAT’s ( most likely with an expensive company specializing in raising their scores) taking every AP class available and negotiating the ins and outs of their first serious love interest. And God forbid they let their gpa drop below a 4.0!

    Then senior year begins. Everyone is excited and feeling on top of the world. The big man on campus….All the kids now have their drivers lic. and are mobil and relieved to have the college applications out of the way. We have a short semester of peace. Until second semester comes with a building mailbox anxiety. The acceptance/ rejection letters start to come. Anticipation is high and at this point so are our kids…they take to drink and to smoke and raves! Who can blame them! They are sooooo over us and our constant badgering and lecturing and prodding! From the moment the fat package arrives from the school of their dreams our kids see a “way out” and know that there is no stopping them. They know that they can behave as they wish and it won’t change the ultimate outcome….FREEDOM! They are off to the land of the young! Most of them will choose colleges with the furthest proximity to home as possible. The expectation of the dorm is palatable and it tastes gooooood.

    Now WE begin to panic. Our carefully honed plan has backfired in our faces. Because it has been so important to us that our child be admitted to one of the most sought after colleges, most competitive and prestigious, we have given up our comfort zone of proximity. All of a sudden the family that is sending their child to a local 2 year junior college to satisfy the general ed requirements, is the family that is having a happy summer. The parents aren’t stressed with huge tuition bills and the kids are relaxed and not worried about separation. Parents feel comfortable that they will have another couple of years to ease out of their family dynamic and the kid can get a local job because he will be able to stay for a while.

    Yes, I agree, we have been a crazy group of parents. We have read books and listened to lectures and compared notes and charts with other parents since the day our little angels were born. We have somehow gotten it into our heads that we can control and micro manage everything in our children’s lives. We have been successful to a point. We have given our children opportunities that have enriched and informed them. We have been uber aware of every aspect of our children’s lives and in the end I am sure that it will benefit them. But now we have to pay the price for having invested so much of ourselves in our children…we have to learn how to “break up”. And break ups are painful. Break ups mean that changes are in store. And changes are scary and wide open.

    A very good friend of mine who now has two boys in college explained to me that I should not think of college as this huge adult thing. She calls freshman college year…13th grade. This screaming 18 year old standing in your kitchen demanding their right to do as they please will once again be calling you for advice. They will have a crumby roommate or a professor that is picking on them. They will have a meltdown when the workload and impending finals sneaks up on their party down ways. In short…they will still need us. Glory be! Who would have thought? My friend says to me…just wait, you think this summer is rough? Ha! Just wait…..

    Yes, I agree that instinct will help us navigate these years ahead. I am finished with reading “How to Raise Your Child” books. At my age if I can’t figure this out from my own experiences and knowledge..no book is going to help me.

UPDATES FROM TRACEY

facebook twitter pinterest pinterest tumblr linkedin RSS Feed

JOIN THE MAILING LIST

TRACEY'S TWEETS